Can't Believe its not Butter ONLY $1.50 at Stop and Shop! Stop & Shop Sale dates: 1/3-1/9 If you need butter, here's a great deal at Stop and Shop! I Can't Believe its Not Butter is on sale 2 for $5 starting 1/3! There is a manufacture coupon for $.50/1 coming 1/5 that you can use to make each one just $1.50! Here's how to do this deal: Buy: I Can't Believe It's Not Butter, $2.50 Use: Save View Post